In October 2000, two months after Burning Man, I visited the
Secoya Indians, a small tribe of 750 in the Ecuadorean Amazon.
The Secoya live on the Rio Aguarico, a river winding through the
largest unroaded stretch of rainforest left in the world. Later
I found out that the Secoya are respected among the neighboring
Indian groups for the purity of their ayahuasca traditions. Like
many Amazonian tribes, the Secoya have been decimated over the
last century by disease and forced acculturation. Their last great
shaman is Don Caesario, a small and frail man in his eighties.
"The Secoya culture is based on communion with the 'heavenly
people' who live along the river and in the sky," said Jonathon,
the ethnobotanist who organized my trip. "They drink yagé
to see them."
Don Caesario usually maintained the distanced but regal demeanor
of someone with command over the deep mystical realms. He resembled
a high Tibetan lama, with Asiatic features and the large ears
of the spiritually advanced. He was often seated quietly on a
hammock, wearing crisscrossing necklaces made from painted seeds,
a knee-length white tunic, and a yellow crown - the traditional
garb of the Secoya.
On my first morning in the jungle, Don Caesario stood inches
away from me in a long dugout canoe. He did not radiate calm.
He was shaking with rage, brandishing a loaded shotgun. A few
days ago, Don Caesario's personal canoe and outboard motor - worth
about $4,000, a lifetime's wages for the average Secoya - had
been stolen. The shaman demanded vengeance.
The expedition included a group of male Secoyas ranging from elders
to young boys. Also a few of the assistants employed by Sentient
Experientials, the tour group, as well as four foolish tourists
including myself. At the helm of the boat, John Bella, a gung-ho
rainforest activist and junior member of the Sentient staff held
a hunting rifle that I hoped he wouldn't try to use. The Sentient
staff was a nebulous group that included a Californian healer,
a sullen Colombian masseuse, a shaggy-bearded cook, others whose
roles I never figured out, and some Quechua Indians. Also traveling
with us was Pablo Amaringo, a painter known for his wonderful
and intricate renderings of ayahuasca visions. A gentle man and
art teacher, Amaringo had been a Peruvian ayahuasquero for many
years, drinking yagé every day. He said he started to have
visions of a witch who was trying to kill him every time he took
yagé. He realized that he would have to kill her if he
wanted to remain a shaman. He decided to give up his practice
instead.
I was sitting next to Mark Miller, a psychologist in a tie-dyed
T-shirt.
"What am I doing here?" Mark asked, as the canoe churned
the waters of the Aguarico River, a muddy channel flowing from
Ecuador to Colombia. "I've got a wife and baby back home."
Don Caesario raised his gun. In Spanish he shouted, "I will
kill the thieves when I find them."
Mark and I had been invited along by Jonathon Miller-Weisberger,
a Berkeley-born, Ecuador-raised, Jewish botanist with a penchant
for quoting the Tao. He had organized this tour. He was also the
founder of Grupo Osanimi, an organization that works on cultural-revival
projects with Ecuadorean tribes. Most of the profits from this
trip would go to benefit Grupo Osanimi's projects. During our
two weeks in the jungle, Jonathon wanted us to get a full dose
of Amazonian life. He explained that theft along the Aguarico,
once almost unheard of, was becoming common as conditions deteriorated:
Mestizos were settling on isolated plots of land between the territories
belonging to the Siona, the Secoya, and the Quechua. They eked
out a living by growing coffee beans and corn, and the most unscrupulous
among them tried to take advantage of the Indians. Meanwhile,
the U.S. government was pouring $1.5 billion into "Plan Colombia,"
making war on the guerillas and attempting to annihilate the coca
fields hidden along the Ecuadorean-Colombian. From planes, they
were spraying massive amounts of "Round-Up," an extremely
poisonous herbicide developed by Monsanto, that apparently laid
waste to large swathes of the jungle, destroying uncountable species
including ayahuasca - even poisoning the fish in the rivers, according
to the Indians. It was unknown to what extent the underground
coca industry was damaged by this indiscriminate assault. The
Secoya feared Colombian guerrillas sneaking into Ecuador - in
fact, the guerrillas might have stolen the canoe. To add to the
anxiety, we were in a region where desperadoes had been kidnapping
American and European oil-company workers with alarming regularity.
The tension thickened to match the equatorial humidity as we scanned
the silent, sticky jungle for enemies.
After several hours, we came upon the canoe chained in front
of a ramshackle homestead. A path from the riverbank led up to
thatched huts shaded by the shiny leaves of coffee bushes. Families
- a few scared men, mothers, children, blacks and Mestizos in
cheap Western clothes - watched us hesitantly from the shore.
It was impossible to read their faces. Were they guilty and ashamed?
Cunning and deceitful? Were other settlers, rifles drawn, targeting
us from behind the trees?
Don Caesario and some of the Secoya jumped into the canoe and
cut it loose. Heated words were exchanged. The shaman's lips trembled
in fury as he raised his shotgun and pointed it at the frightened
leaders of the homesteaders.
Mark and I looked at each other. We were caught between our shaman's
sight line and his enemies. It did not seem like a safe place
to be.
Jonathon leapt out of the boat and stepped in front of the settlers.
The Secoya gunned the motor and piloted Don Caesario away. Shots
rang out - the sound of our spiritual leader emptying his chambers
into the air.
We met Jonathon in Quito, Ecuador's capital, where the country's
sudden switch to a U.S.-dollar economy, due to an IMF-engineered
debt crisis, was spurring massive inflation and riots. Our group
was booked at Casa del Sol, a small hotel staffed by Quechua Indians,
on Avenida Jose Calama. Calama was turista central, a street of
hotels, bars, and hostels. Recently wired to the Net, it was home
to an alarming number of new cyber cafes - pool.net, papaya.net,
earth.net - each one blaring pop music and selling multihued fruit
drinks. Young backpackers, ranging from the hip and dreadlocked
to the preppy and generic, sat before banks of terminals, e-mailing
their friends back home about their romantic hook-ups, visa problems,
and stomach aches. But the multicultural buzz of the cafes was
dampened by the guards in black uniforms who stood in the street
with dogs and automatic weapons, protecting the gringos from the
ever-present threat of kidnappers and thieves.
Jonathon had rented a bus to take us from Quito. We drove through
the cloud forests of the Andes, descending into the Amazon in
a bumpy twelve-hour ride. This ride tattooed on our eyeballs the
devastation wrought by the oil industry. The roads built by the
oil companies had opened up the jungle to loggers and poor, desperate
Mestizo settlers. All thoughts of visionary Indians and mystic
revelations were wiped away by the blunt reality of the pipeline
running inexorably beside the road, surrounded by recently clear-cut
land, sucking the marrow out of the jungle.
We spent the night at Lago Agrio, the Dodge City of Ecuador,
population twenty-five thousand and growing. It was a ragged boomtown
of two industries: oil and prostitution. Ten years ago, the area
was virgin rainforest; now it was slashed-and-burnt scrub. Once
it is destroyed, the rainforest does not regenerate itself, and
the local climate quickly becomes too hot and dry for farming.
The land, for all practical purposes, becomes useless.
Our bus driver and his buddy returned with sheepish grins from
a night on the town. They bragged about the teenage prostitutes
who could be had for $2 at the local whorehouses. I thought of
the chain of dehumanization and exploitation beginning with the
oil company's quest for profit, the American consumer's avidity
for cheap gas to fuel SUVs, the corrupt governments of bankrupt
Third World countries seeking payoffs, ending with despoiled rainforests
and teenage Mestizo girls contracting AIDS from drunk ditch diggers
in Third World backwaters. Benjamin's "religion of destruction"
was performing its good works.
The next day, we rode for four hours on motorized canoes, on
the mud-brown Rio Aguarico, ever-deeper into the jungle, surrounded
by its secretive green density. We passed through the territories
of neighboring Indian tribes. As night fell, we were brought to
the rough stone steps leading up to the house of Don Caesario.
Over the last three hundred years, the Secoya have lost their
ancestral homeland and 98 percent of their population. Decimated
by the diseases of the Spanish conquerors, enslaved and forced
to work on rubber plantations, a tribe of more than thirty thousand
has been reduced to a paltry 750. Almost half live on the Rio
Aguarico, the rest in the remote jungles of Peru.
Across the Amazon, Indian cultures have been compromised and
quickly destroyed through contact with the West. Vast treasures
of botanical knowledge and linguistic and spiritual traditions
are already gone. As the force of the colonialists and their Christian
missionaries overwhelmed the Indians, followed by ruthless rubber
tappers and then even more ruthless oil corporations, the tribal
shamans lost their authority. Many were accused - often by missionaries
- of witchcraft. Shamans have been murdered by Indians looking
for scapegoats to blame for the collapse of their world.
In the U.S. and Europe, shamans have been reappropriated as heroic
figures by anthropologists, psychedelic avatars like Terence McKenna,
and New Age popularists. But the fact is that ambiguity hovers
over shamanism wherever it appears. The magical powers acquired
through disciplined use of ayahuasca can be turned to good or
evil. The Yagé Drinker is the autobiography of the famous
Secoya shaman Fernando Payaguaje, compiled from interviews with
his grandsons. Payaguaje spoke about the temptation of sorcery:
"Some people drink yagé only to the point of reaching
the power to practice witchcraft; with these crafts they can kill
people. A much greater effort and consumption of yagé are
required to reach the highest level, where one gains access to
the visions and powers of healing." Michael Harner, studying
the shamanism of the Jivaro (or Shuar) Indians of the Amazon,
noted that Jivaro shamans wielded magical darts, tsentsak, that
could be used either to cure or kill. The Jivaro, like most tribal
groups, lived in constant fear of witchcraft. Sorcery is the inescapable
shadow side of shamanism.
The modern West, engaged in a neo-shamanic renaissance, has so
far ignored the ambiguous aspects of shamanism. The American anthropologist
Michael F. Brown finds it unsettling "that New Age America
seeks to embrace shamanism without any appreciation of its context.
For my Santa Fe acquaintances, tribal lore is a supermarket from
which they choose some tidbits while spurning others." Among
the Indians, "Shamanism affirms life but also spawns violence
and death. The beauty of shamanism is matched by its power - and
like all forms of power found in society, it inspires its share
of discontent."
Westerners who have rediscovered magic and spirit as living facts
of human existence - transformed in their own inner being by the
knowledge - yearn to reintroduce these forces to the contemporary
world. Yet these elemental forces cannot be divorced from ambiguity,
from danger. The power can be easily misused or distorted. Magic
shades into witchcraft, communicating with the spirit realm is
a step away from occult invocation. Bringing this knowledge back
into contemporary life requires reckoning with dark forces - a
balancing act which is also part of indigenous shamanism.
"Ayahuasca tourism," a growing phenomenon throughout
South America, reflects the surge of underground interest in ayahuasca
in the United States. Precise figures are hard to come by, but
one could estimate there are hundreds of shamans, ranging from
authentic to ambiguous to fraudulent, receiving thousands of Western
visitors annually. Websites devoted to the vine keep multiplying,
along with new books: The Cosmic Serpent, by Jeremy Narby; Ayahuasca:
Human Consciousness and the Spirits of Nature, edited by Ralph
Metzner; and Ayahuasca Visions, by Pablo Amaringo and Eduardo
Luna, to name only a few. Magazines like Shaman's Drum promote
group tours to visit Mestizo shamans across the Amazon for a few
weeks of fasting and "journeying."
Some critics attack these excursions for marketing native spirituality
and further degrading Amazonian traditions. The anthropologist
Marlene Dobkin Del Rios, author of Visionary Vine, a book on yagé
healing in Peru, believes that Americans are driven to shamanic
adventures by the syndrome of the "empty self," the
inner void left by our materialistic culture. In the introduction
to his book Ayahuasca Analogues, Jonathan Ott bemoans ayahuasca
tourism in the Amazon, "which can only disrupt the evanescent
remnant of preliterate religiosity struggling to make a place
for itself in the modern world, while attracting the wrong kind
of political attention to ayahuasca."
It seems to me that these perspectives are short-sighted - not
only because the shamans themselves have the vision of sharing
their knowledge with Westerners, but also because yagé
tourism, if it is done conscientiously, is a force that can help
to preserve indigenous traditions at this point. This is what
seems to be happening with the Secoyas. There are not going to
be any "pure" Indian cultures anymore, certainly no
illiterate ones. After decades of seeing their cultures trashed
by the missionaries, assaulted by the Western governments, overrun
by corporate emissaries, the Indians need to know that certain
groups of rich Westerners value their knowledge and history. The
yagé tours are, in fact, beneficial to both sides: The
shamans desperately need the revenue, and we - equally desperately
- need the revelations.
Sentient Experientials did not explicitly use yagé to
promote their journeys to Secoya territory. Don Caesario was not
paid for his shamanism - instead, he was compensated for his hospitality
with gifts, such as his house and canoe. Beholden to no one, he
could skip the ceremonies entirely if he did not like the energy
of the group.
I fervently hoped he wouldn't do that to us.
After the recovery of the boat, we settled in for a twelve-day
stay. The women set up tents, while most of the men slept on hammocks
under the shaman's thatched roof, where the elders and an ever-rotating
number of Secoya families also lived. Several times I returned
to my hammock in the afternoon to find a tiny baby sleeping in
it.
Among our group of hopeful psychonauts, the largest contingent,
surprisingly, was made up of feisty middle-aged women - social
workers, therapists, academics, and housewives - some white-haired,
most wearing fanny packs and Tevas. Two were graduates of the
California Institute of Integral Studies, a kind of New Age think
tank. There was also Octavia Martin, a pensive Native American
artist who lived on a reservation in Massachusetts. We did not
seem likely candidates for a trek into the deep jungle; our campsite
was a three-hour canoe trip away from a phone or hospital. I was
especially worried about Annie Bush, a psychotherapist whose large
body suggested the soft excesses of suburban living (later she
outhiked me through the forest). There were two other guys in
their thirties following a personal "vision quest."
"I do what the Great Spirit tells me to do," said Mark,
the therapist, only half-joking. He had gone on a thousand-mile
peyote hunt, the annual rite of the Huichol Indians in Mexico,
with a Huichol shamaness. Nervous about yagé, he called
taking psychedelics "going into 'The Mystery.'"
Andrew Doxer, a rail-thin teacher in a Boston after-school program,
regularly visited a Mestizo shaman in Peru, to take yagé
and fast. He wanted to follow the "shamanic path." The
first time he drank the brew, Andrew said he saw a visible current
of energy flow up into him from the floor. He realized, in a flash,
that he should be working with children. After that, he stopped
having visions, which was frustrating. Yet he was ready for another
dose.
Our group also included Tamara Swingle, a cheerful twenty-three-year-old
botany student from Washington State, small, blond, and muscular.
John Emerson, a well-traveled beekeeper from Hawaii, looked like
a spy from a Graham Green novel in his Panama hat and khaki suit.
Jean Michel Taub, a French businessman, reminded me of Pepe Le
Peu, the insufferable French skunk from Warner Bros. cartoons.
While mocking American consumerism, Jean-Michel brought a handheld
global-positioning device to the jungle. (He offered to explain
its workings to Don Caesario: "No, thanks," the shaman
replied gruffly. "I already know where I am.")
Almost instantly, our group started to succumb to the jungle
conditions. On the second day, Tammy, seemingly the fittest of
us all, caught a raging stomach bug. Hae Soog Jo, a Korean academic
from Berkeley, developed a severe infection on her foot. A few
others bumbled into a hive and were attacked by angry bees. The
casualties crept back to their tents or hammocks, where they lay,
dazed by the intense midday heat, making the rest of us feel lucky.